PLAN YOUR VISIT

Italian Scenes at Ruthmere

Lake Como in the Italian Lake District. From https://discovernorthernitaly.com/lake-como-or-lake-garda/

If you have taken a tour at Ruthmere, you probably remember some of the Italian scenes found within the house. It’s also commonly known that Italy was Albert and Elizabeth Beardsley’s favorite place to travel and they did so many times. In this article, we are going to explore where we find Italy inside Ruthmere as well as talk about other more subtle Italian influences found in the mansion.

First of all, let's talk about the Lake District in Italy where Albert and Elizabeth likely traveled. This is an area of northern Italy that is known for several lakes nestled up against the Alps and the border of Switzerland. In fact, some of the lakes actually extend into Switzerland. There are several main lakes in the district which are Lake Garda, Lake Como, Lake Maggiore, Lake Iseo, Lake Orta and Lake Lugano. These lakes are all relatively close to each other, but each lake maintains its own unique aesthetic from the varied landscapes and gardens. Yes, the Lake District is not just known for its beauty from the water, but also from its spectacular gardens. 

Italian Lake District villa gardens were influenced by Italian Renaissance characteristics and something Edith Wharton calls Italian “garden magic” in her book Italian Villas and Their Gardens. A house or villa, the garden, and the natural landscape must not only complement each other but also be connected in subtle and seamless ways to be considered garden magic. When you look out from the villa, you should be able to see the garden and the natural landscape fitting together as if it is one composition or painting. The garden also connects to the house and should fit into the architectural lines of the house as if it was planned to be part of the house.  Meanwhile, the garden should also have sunny grass, shady walks, and an ornamental garden with paths that are all easily accessible to the house or the natural landscape beyond the garden. This provides accessible comfort for all different types of weather as well as quick changes of weather. The parterre, or ornamental garden, was also planned with the natural landscape in mind to create a seamless transition. According to Edith Wharton, Italian gardens are not something that can be copied by a simple checklist, but instead they are copied in spirit from these different variables working together. 

Elizabeth Beardsley in her garden

Elizabeth and Albert Beardsley outside St. Mark’s Basilica in Venice

Painted glass window in Ruthmere’s Game Room

The mural in Ruthmere’s Game Room tunnel, which leads to the greenhouse

The painted velvet walls of Ruthmere’s dining room

Elizabeth Beardsley loved gardening. Did she love gardening before she visited Italy? Or did her visits to Italy influence her love of gardening? Lakes Como, Maggiore and Garda were popular travel destinations for the wealthy around 1900 because of the dramatic landscape, architecture and luxurious hotels. We also know that Albert and Elizabeth visited Venice because we have a picture of them in front of St. Marks Square in Venice, which is on the coast of Northern Italy and somewhat close to the Lake District.

The Ruthmere mansion has many different Italian influences, both overt and subtle. Firstly, in the southwest corner of the Game Room, there are four oil-painted-on-glass windows depicting the Lake District of Italy. These windows are naturally lit from the outside and are one small example of the Beardsleys seemingly creating their own Italian villa in Indiana.

 The next example is in the tunnel that leads from the Game Room to the greenhouse outside. The long tunnel walls are covered in canvas murals of trees and the natural landscape of the Italian Lake District. And these walls are only a passageway to the greenhouse, but an important passageway to provide a comfortable transition to the greenhouse garden. But before we get to the greenhouse and the garden outside, we must mention the dining room. There are painted velvet murals covering the walls that depict the Lake District of Italy. As you sit at the table in the dining room, these murals surround you and it's easy to imagine what it’s like to dine al fresco in Italy. Perhaps the Beardsleys wanted to feel like they were dining in Italy during a cold winter in Indiana.

All these references to the Italian landscape, Ruthmere’s garden views and Indiana’s landscape are easily accessible throughout most of the house. In addition to the depictions of Italy already mentioned, Elizabeth’s rooms have wonderful views of Ruthmere’s front garden and river landscape upstairs and Albert’s room has a great view of the house garden and woodland lot outside Ruthmere’s garden walls. One also has a good view of the garden from the kitchen, a spot that Stella Beardsley particularly loved, and a great view of the garden from the dining room and drawing room.

The view from Elizabeth’s morning room as of November, 2025

The view from Albert’s room as of November, 2025

Under the loggia with the door to the greenhouse

Now let's go out the front door of the house to Ruthmere's Piazza. On this covered veranda, you can see most of the main borders of Ruthmere’s garden. Geometric patterns are created with stone and brick fence walls. A balustrade makes up the fence wall both on the piazza as well as the borders of the property. The piazza also provides an important Italian Renaissance feature of a higher vantage point to encourage seeing the landscape beyond the garden borders. Yet another Italian feature known as the loggia provides a covered pathway from the piazza to the greenhouse. Just off the piazza is a parterre, which is done in a French-style blue and white garden, but this style of garden was originally inspired by the Italian Renaissance garden. Their beds use symmetrical patterns, stone paths and a water feature, all of which are found in Ruthmere’s garden. All of these garden features are contained within the fence lines of the house, but there is more. On the east side of the house outside the fence, there is a wooded lot full of trees. Again, this natural landscape is an important variable of that Italian “garden magic.” Another important part of the landscape lies to the south side of the Ruthmere property where you find the St. Joseph and Elkhart rivers. These rivers are not part of the property, but they are easily seen from the house and garden and are easily accessible from the garden. Perhaps Albert and Elizabeth reminisced of their favorite lake in Italy when looking out onto the confluence of the Elkhart and St. Joseph rivers.

Ruthmere’s wedding garden & greenhouse

Whether you have been to Italy already or you have it on your list of places to travel, come take a tour of Ruthmere to see and imagine why the Beardsleys put so many Italian features in their home. Maybe you want to study the murals of the Lake District in the game room or perhaps you are interested in pretending what eating al fresco in Italy might look like in the dining room. Whatever your goal, I suggest trying to feel the spirit of that Italian “garden magic” while sitting on the piazza waiting for your tour to start.